What is a service level agreement?

A Service Level Agreement (SLA) is a formal contract between a service provider and their client that defines the expected level of service delivery, performance metrics, and responsibilities of both parties. In the maintenance context, let’s explore this concept in detail:

Core Components of a Maintenance SLA:

Response and Resolution Times

The guaranteed response and resolution timeframes are at the heart of any maintenance SLA. These are typically broken down by priority levels – for instance, a critical equipment failure might require a 2-hour response and a 4-hour resolution time.

At the same time, a minor issue could have a 24-hour response window.

When reviewing an SLA, consider how these priorities are defined, as what you consider critical may not align with the provider’s definition.

Performance Metrics and Measurement

The SLA should clearly outline how service quality will be measured. Common maintenance metrics include equipment uptime percentage, mean time between failures (MTBF), and first-time fix rate.

For example, an SLA might guarantee 98% uptime for critical equipment or an 85% first-time fix rate. The agreement should specify exactly how these metrics are calculated and what monitoring tools or methods will be used to track them.

Scope of Services

This section details exactly what maintenance services are covered – perhaps more importantly, what isn’t.

For instance, an HVAC maintenance SLA might include regular inspections, filter changes, and emergency repairs but exclude complete system replacement or upgrades.

Look for clear definitions of what constitutes routine maintenance versus additional billable services provided.

Financial Terms and Penalties

The agreement should specify not only the base service costs but also what happens when service levels aren’t met.

Many SLAs include financial penalties or service credits when the provider fails to meet agreed-upon metrics.

For example, if monthly uptime falls below the guaranteed 98%, you might receive a 10% credit on that month’s service fee.

Ensure these penalties are meaningful enough to motivate good service and customer satisfaction but not so punitive that they could damage your working relationship.

Communication Protocols

A well-structured SLA establishes clear communication channels and reporting requirements. This includes how to submit service requests, escalation procedures, and regular performance review meetings for unresolved issues and overall service availability.

The agreement should specify what reports you’ll receive, their frequency, and the key performance indicators they’ll cover.

Elements of Maintenance Service Level Agreement
Data and Illustration: WorkTrek

What should you watch out for when reviewing an SLA?

Flexibility and Scalability

Consider whether the SLA can adapt to your changing needs and provide the service expected.

Can service levels be adjusted as equipment ages? How are additional assets handled? How is service performance measured? How can you verify service levels and technical quality of work?

Look for provisions allowing periodic review and adjustment of service levels without requiring a contract renegotiation.

Exit Clauses and Transition Support

Even the best relationships sometimes end.

Exit clauses in an SLA define the conditions and processes under which either party can terminate the agreement.

Think of them as the “prenuptial agreement” of business relationships. These clauses typically cover three main scenarios:

First, there’s termination for convenience, where either party can end the agreement after giving proper notice, even if nothing is wrong.

For example, a company might bring IT services in-house and need to end its external IT service provider and support contract.

Second, we have a termination for cause, which happens when one party fails to meet its obligations and does not meet or manage customer expectations.

For instance, the client might invoke this clause if a service provider consistently fails to meet the agreed-upon uptime requirements, including SLA metrics.

Third, there’s termination due to external factors, such as bankruptcy or a change in control of either company.

Now, let’s talk about transition, which is equally important but often overlooked.

Transition provisions outline business process metrics how services will be handed over to the client or to a new service provider. This process is similar to handing over a complex project to a new team – it needs to be carefully planned and executed.

A good transition plan typically includes:

  1. Knowledge Transfer: All processes, procedures, and systems must be documented. This might involve training sessions in which the current provider teaches the client’s team or the new provider about the systems and processes.
  2. Data Migration: All relevant data must be transferred securely and in a usable format. For example, if you’re changing CRM providers, you must ensure all customer data is correctly exported and imported into the new system.
  3. Asset Transfer: Any physical or digital assets must be returned or transferred. This could include hardware, software licenses, or access credentials.
  4. Timeline and Milestones: A clear schedule for the transition period, usually ranging from a few months to a year, depending on the complexity of services.
SLA Transition plan components

Data and Illustration: WorkTrek

A real-world example might be a company using an external provider for customer support services.

The exit clause might specify that they can terminate with 90 days’ notice, and the transition plan would detail how:

  • Customer data will be exported
  • Ongoing support tickets will be handled
  • Knowledge base articles will be transferred
  • Support staff will be trained
  • Phone numbers and email addresses will be redirected

The key is that both exit clauses and transition provisions should be detailed enough to prevent disputes but flexible enough to accommodate various scenarios.

They should also include cost provisions, such as who pays for what during the transition period.

Force Majeure and Exceptions

Force majeure sounds like a fancy legal jargon. It is a standard contractual clause that frees both parties from liability or obligation when an extraordinary event or circumstance beyond their control prevents them from fulfilling their obligations under the contract.

These extraordinary circumstances, often called “acts of God” or force majeure events, typically include:

  • Natural disasters (earthquakes, floods, hurricanes)
  • War or armed conflicts
  • Government actions or changes in law
  • Strikes and labor disputes
  • Epidemics or pandemics
  • Severe supply chain disruptions

For example, if a company agrees to deliver products but can’t fulfill the order because a hurricane destroyed their factory, a force majeure clause would protect them from being sued for breach of contract.

For a force majeure clause to be invoked:

  1. The event must be beyond the reasonable control of the affected party
  2. The event must make performance impossible or impracticable
  3. The affected party must take reasonable steps to mitigate the impact
  4. The affected party must typically notify the other party within a specified timeframe

While standard force majeure clauses are typical, be wary of broad exceptions that could leave you vulnerable during critical situations.

Resource Commitments

Resource commitments in a maintenance SLA define the people, equipment, tools, and materials dedicated to keeping facilities and equipment operational.

Think of it as creating a comprehensive maintenance strategy that ensures key components of everything from HVAC systems to industrial machinery stay running efficiently.

Personnel Resources

In maintenance, your human resource commitments must be highly specific in terms of technical expertise.

For example, if you’re providing an industrial equipment maintenance service desk here, you might commit to having:

  • A dedicated maintenance supervisor is available during all production shifts
  • Certified HVAC technicians on call 24/7 for critical cooling system failures
  • Licensed electricians are available within 30 minutes for electrical emergencies
  • Millwrights scheduled for weekly preventive maintenance rounds
  • Specialized equipment operators for tasks like crane maintenance or hydraulic system repairs

You should also account for coverage during different shifts and emergency scenarios.

For instance, if a critical production line goes down at 2 AM, you must specify exactly who responds and how quickly they can arrive.

Technical Resources

For maintenance services, the technical support resources are particularly equipment-heavy. This includes:

  • Diagnostic tools (vibration analyzers, thermal imaging cameras, ultrasonic testing equipment)
  • Maintenance management software (CMMS) licenses for all technicians
  • Specialized repair equipment (welding machines, hydraulic tools, calibration devices)
  • Safety equipment and PPE inventory
  • Mobile maintenance units fully equipped with common repair parts

For example, suppose you’re maintaining a manufacturing facility. In that case, you need to specify the standard toolsets and specialized equipment like precision alignment tools for motor coupling maintenance or oil analysis equipment for predictive maintenance programs.

Time Commitments

In maintenance, time commitments often revolve around response times and scheduled maintenance windows:

  • Emergency response times (e.g., 15 minutes for production-critical failures)
  • Preventive maintenance schedules (detailed by equipment type)
  • Planned shutdown windows for major repairs
  • Regular inspection intervals
  • Time allocated for equipment testing and commissioning

Financial Resources

Maintenance-specific financial commitments should be outlined:

  • Spare parts inventory investment
  • Emergency repair fund allocations
  • Predictive maintenance technology investments
  • Training for new equipment or technologies
  • Certification renewals for specialized technicians

Review Process

The maintenance industry requires particularly rigorous review processes:

  1. Equipment Performance Tracking: Monitor mean time between failures (MTBF) and mean time to repair (MTTR) to evaluate if resource commitments are adequate.
  2. Maintenance Effectiveness Metrics: Track key performance indicators, such as the planned vs. unplanned maintenance ratio, equipment availability, and maintenance backlog.
  3. Capacity Planning: Evaluate how resource needs change as equipment ages or when new equipment is installed.

Here’s a practical example of a manufacturing plant maintenance SLA:

  • 4 certified maintenance technicians per shift (3 shifts)
  • 1 reliability engineer for a predictive maintenance program
  • Full diagnostic equipment set, including vibration analyzers and infrared cameras
  • $100,000 minimum critical spare parts inventory
  • 30-minute maximum response time for critical equipment failures
  • Weekly preventive maintenance schedule requiring 80 technician-hours
  • Monthly equipment reliability review meetings

Resources for SLA Management include:

  • Weekly maintenance planning meetings
  • Monthly performance review sessions
  • Quarterly audits of preventive maintenance compliance
  • Annual review of maintenance strategies and resource allocation

The key is ensuring your resource commitments align with the criticality of the equipment being maintained and the facility’s production demands.

For instance, a food processing plant might require more frequent sanitation maintenance resources than a warehouse facility. In contrast, a chemical plant might need specialized safety equipment and certified technicians for hazardous area maintenance.

Implementation Tips

When implementing a new SLA, consider starting with a pilot period (perhaps 3-6 months) where metrics are tracked but penalties aren’t enforced.

This allows both parties to validate that the service levels are realistic and the measurement systems are accurate.

Regular Review

Regular review meetings are crucial – monthly or quarterly, depending on the service complexity. Use these to discuss all performance levels and trends, not just individual incidents. Look for patterns that might indicate underlying issues before they become critical problems.

Documentation

Document your current maintenance performance metrics before entering a technology vendor contract or an SLA. This baseline helps ensure the new agreement improves service levels rather than just maintaining the status quo.

Remember that the best SLAs are living documents that evolve with your relationship with the service provider.

Build mechanisms for regular reviews and updates to keep the agreement aligned with your changing business needs.

Get a Free WorkTrek Demo

Let's show you how WorkTrek can help you optimize your maintenance operation.

Try for free